My computer battery died in the last 5-10 minutes of the forum, but I don't think much was missed. Bolton answered another question regarding the UN, and his response eventually came back to how the US is a great nation that has the power and responsibility to promote peace throughout the world. The forum then ended with thunderous applause for all participants.
Here a few of the aspects that I personally thought made the forum a great success:
~ A terrific moderator. Stephanopoulos, in his experience as a journalist and weekly television host, clearly knew when a participant had answered the question fully and when to switch to the other participant or another question. Both Bolton and Carville appeared to be given roughly equal amounts of time to address an issue, even if it went back and forth a bit.
~ Pertinent questions. The event was called the "KPU Forum on Current Affairs," and that's exactly what it was. Stephanopoulous knew when to switch to a new issue and gave an appropriate amount of time for both major issues and audience questions. The panelists answered questions on both foreign and domestic issues to the best of their ability. The audience questions were much more detailed and dealt with specific issues, but I think the majority of attendees were content with the discussion before the individual queries.
~ A sense of humor from all participants. Carville rarely-- perhaps never-- answered a question without a crazy Southern idiom, living up to his nickname of the Ragin' Cajun. Bolton also demonstrated a light-hearted side, smiling and mustering a stern "good luck" when asked by an AU undergrad about how to grow a mustache like his own. Stephanopoulos knew when to crack a smile and dive into the next question before the ongoing debate got too heated.
All in all, an interesting event with lots of insight from two prominent political figures. Let's hope that the KPU puts on equally entertaining and intellectually stimulating events next year.
Monday, April 16, 2007
Questions from the audience
The panelists take on questions from the American University audience. A handful of audience members trickle out of the arena for this portion.
Bolton takes a strongly worded question about what he learned after working at the United Nations. "The organization is in desperate need of reform." (Much applause to that one throughout the audience.) He proposes a move to voluntary contributions to the United Nations as a first step in such reforms.
Bolton also discusses North Korea and our nation's attempt to halt their developments of nuclear weapons. It's clear that they are making no serious attempt to stop those programs, and diplomacy is clearly not going to work in this situation.
Carville finally gets called back to his podium after Stephanopoulos asks for someone to step forward with a question that's not for Bolton. Congress is going to be involved in clarifying the next course of action in this war in Iraq, Carville says. The previous Congress "was not diligent enough" in expressing their desires in what should happen in this war.
Bolton takes a strongly worded question about what he learned after working at the United Nations. "The organization is in desperate need of reform." (Much applause to that one throughout the audience.) He proposes a move to voluntary contributions to the United Nations as a first step in such reforms.
Bolton also discusses North Korea and our nation's attempt to halt their developments of nuclear weapons. It's clear that they are making no serious attempt to stop those programs, and diplomacy is clearly not going to work in this situation.
Carville finally gets called back to his podium after Stephanopoulos asks for someone to step forward with a question that's not for Bolton. Congress is going to be involved in clarifying the next course of action in this war in Iraq, Carville says. The previous Congress "was not diligent enough" in expressing their desires in what should happen in this war.
Labels:
audience,
Congress,
Iraq war,
North Korea,
questions,
United Nations
2008 Presidential Election
Carville: Barack Obama represents something different from all the other candidates, and that's what people want right now. Hilary needs to show how she can be different from all other politicians to have a strong showing in the Iowa primary. And I haven't seen a poll in Iowa that Edwards wasn't leading.
Bolton: I think Republicans would rather run against Obama. Hilary's support is very strong and might be hard to break. "I think it's gonna be a tough election for Republicans." In addition, an anti-war stance from the Republican Party will not win any more votes.
Carville: That just reaffirms my point of "why Republicans will get spanked again in 2008." But my big fear is that the Republicans might bring a new person in with a fresh face, but frankly I think there's no one in the Republican race right now that come across as a really strong candidate. Polling might show candidates 10 or 15 points ahead of their primary opponents, but it's definitely going to be closer than that.
Bolton: I think Republicans would rather run against Obama. Hilary's support is very strong and might be hard to break. "I think it's gonna be a tough election for Republicans." In addition, an anti-war stance from the Republican Party will not win any more votes.
Carville: That just reaffirms my point of "why Republicans will get spanked again in 2008." But my big fear is that the Republicans might bring a new person in with a fresh face, but frankly I think there's no one in the Republican race right now that come across as a really strong candidate. Polling might show candidates 10 or 15 points ahead of their primary opponents, but it's definitely going to be closer than that.
Pressure on Gonzalez
Stephanopoulos: Is the President putting too much pressure on Attorney General Gonzalez?
Bolton: No he hasn't, and as an alumnus of the Department of Justice, I'm befuddled about how we got to this point.
Carville: Let me clarify it for you then. Just to be perfectly honest, the Democrats don't trust these guys very much. We believe there's a "superb chance" that the Justice Department was using the firings as a political move.
Stephanopoulos: What advice would you give the President now?
Carville: I guess I'd ask, why do we care about Gonzalez right now? "Why not get someone new in and change that?" I think it's important to understand what the Democrats think here. I don't know if they'll be able to prove it. There's nothing that's happened since this started that wouldn't make a Democrat think, "Something smells in Denmark here, and it aint cheese."
Bolton: I think there's sufficient evidence that they took 2 years of reviewing these attorneys before removing them. They could've been like President Clinton and removed all 93 U.S. attorneys when he came into office. "The Democrats see a chance to take a political shot, and they're gonna take it." (When Stephanopoulos asks if Gonzalez will survive, Bolton's response is a long, "Uhhhhh....")
Bolton: No he hasn't, and as an alumnus of the Department of Justice, I'm befuddled about how we got to this point.
Carville: Let me clarify it for you then. Just to be perfectly honest, the Democrats don't trust these guys very much. We believe there's a "superb chance" that the Justice Department was using the firings as a political move.
Stephanopoulos: What advice would you give the President now?
Carville: I guess I'd ask, why do we care about Gonzalez right now? "Why not get someone new in and change that?" I think it's important to understand what the Democrats think here. I don't know if they'll be able to prove it. There's nothing that's happened since this started that wouldn't make a Democrat think, "Something smells in Denmark here, and it aint cheese."
Bolton: I think there's sufficient evidence that they took 2 years of reviewing these attorneys before removing them. They could've been like President Clinton and removed all 93 U.S. attorneys when he came into office. "The Democrats see a chance to take a political shot, and they're gonna take it." (When Stephanopoulos asks if Gonzalez will survive, Bolton's response is a long, "Uhhhhh....")
Labels:
Democrats,
Gonzalez,
Justice Department,
President Bush
Iran's nuclear capabilities
Stephanopoulos: Iran might be able to develop nuclear weapons in as quickly as two years, according to one expert, as opposed to 7-10 years as previously estimated. What should our course of action be?
Bolton: "I don't think a military option is the preferred option." The estimates of when Iran will have a nuclear weapon vary a lot, and they've been secretly trying to develop these nuclear weapons for 20 years now. The problem is that Iran openly says what their intentions are, "and we have to act now for our security's sake." We need to substantially apply more pressure on them.
Carville: You say we can't wait to take action and apply more pressure, so why don't we bomb them now? "The world isn't going to believe anything we do right now." If we take action, we need to include other nations, because American credibility has dropped dramatically. "If we try anything over there, we better damn sure have proof." I'd be much more worried about Pakistan in five or ten years from now "because they already have a firecracker."
Bolton: "I don't think a military option is the preferred option." The estimates of when Iran will have a nuclear weapon vary a lot, and they've been secretly trying to develop these nuclear weapons for 20 years now. The problem is that Iran openly says what their intentions are, "and we have to act now for our security's sake." We need to substantially apply more pressure on them.
Carville: You say we can't wait to take action and apply more pressure, so why don't we bomb them now? "The world isn't going to believe anything we do right now." If we take action, we need to include other nations, because American credibility has dropped dramatically. "If we try anything over there, we better damn sure have proof." I'd be much more worried about Pakistan in five or ten years from now "because they already have a firecracker."
Iraq War Part 2
Stephanopoulos proposes a recent poll by ABC that many Americans don't feel the war is worth the effort anymore.
Bolton compares modern-day Iraq to Yugoslavia, which fell into turmoil and war after it was liberated from communism. He says establishing a strong government as quickly as possible in Iraq-- which we should've done sooner than now, he reiterates-- will prevent those same problems of civil war and political chaos in Iraq. Bolton does not disagree that it may be time to let Iraq take full control of the problem. Our strategic interest before the war and after the war was the strategic objective of not allowing terrorist groups to form in this society, he said. "This is why we should've gone in the beginning and put responsibility in Iraq hands."
Carville says "a quagmire is a quagmire is a quagmire", and we should've thought about this before going into it. We knew what was there and what we were getting into. There are a number of Democratic responses to this war. "I think the best thing to do is say we're outta there in six months," and we have to make up our mind about what we want to do there at this moment in time. "Open-ended paternalism is not an option," he said, comparing the situation to a kid spending too much time trying to graduate from college.
Bolton compares modern-day Iraq to Yugoslavia, which fell into turmoil and war after it was liberated from communism. He says establishing a strong government as quickly as possible in Iraq-- which we should've done sooner than now, he reiterates-- will prevent those same problems of civil war and political chaos in Iraq. Bolton does not disagree that it may be time to let Iraq take full control of the problem. Our strategic interest before the war and after the war was the strategic objective of not allowing terrorist groups to form in this society, he said. "This is why we should've gone in the beginning and put responsibility in Iraq hands."
Carville says "a quagmire is a quagmire is a quagmire", and we should've thought about this before going into it. We knew what was there and what we were getting into. There are a number of Democratic responses to this war. "I think the best thing to do is say we're outta there in six months," and we have to make up our mind about what we want to do there at this moment in time. "Open-ended paternalism is not an option," he said, comparing the situation to a kid spending too much time trying to graduate from college.
Introductions & The Iraq War
The crowd welcomes the forum participants with an enthusiastic standing ovation. Taylor Robinson, director of the KPU, opens with a quote from JFK and a moment of silence for the victims of the Virginia Tech shootings earlier today. Robinson recaps the events and speakers that the KPU brought to campus this year and introduces "the most candid men in America." Applause breaks out a little early in one section of the audience as John Bolton is introduced.
As George Stephanopoulos takes his place at the center podium for a "no-holds-barred" debate, he jumps straight into the first issue up for discussion tonight: the war in Iraq.
Bolton: There are two parts of this war to consider. Congress was right to consider the regime of Saddam Hussein a threat to the United States. However, the conduct and affairs that occurred after that should've been done differently. We should've returned authority back to the Iraqis more quickly. In addition, the issue of inspecting for WMDs in Iraq was irrelevant. The concern about WMD materials and chemical weapons came from his declarations of having such weapons in the 1990s during the Gulf War, and Saddam had no proof or evidence that he destroyed those weapons by the early 2000s.
Carville: Democrats lost their nerve in standing up again this war in Iraq in late 2002 and 2003. There was no evidence of weapons of mass destruction, but the political pressue was on to go to war. No recollection of anyone saying we have to invade because there's no record of Iraqus not destroying their weapons. I remember "talking about smoking guns and mushroom clouds," but we have to remember that we eventually kicked the weapons' inspectors from the UN out of Iraq. There was a shift in rationale. Apparently it was a concern about bookkeeping there.
As George Stephanopoulos takes his place at the center podium for a "no-holds-barred" debate, he jumps straight into the first issue up for discussion tonight: the war in Iraq.
Bolton: There are two parts of this war to consider. Congress was right to consider the regime of Saddam Hussein a threat to the United States. However, the conduct and affairs that occurred after that should've been done differently. We should've returned authority back to the Iraqis more quickly. In addition, the issue of inspecting for WMDs in Iraq was irrelevant. The concern about WMD materials and chemical weapons came from his declarations of having such weapons in the 1990s during the Gulf War, and Saddam had no proof or evidence that he destroyed those weapons by the early 2000s.
Carville: Democrats lost their nerve in standing up again this war in Iraq in late 2002 and 2003. There was no evidence of weapons of mass destruction, but the political pressue was on to go to war. No recollection of anyone saying we have to invade because there's no record of Iraqus not destroying their weapons. I remember "talking about smoking guns and mushroom clouds," but we have to remember that we eventually kicked the weapons' inspectors from the UN out of Iraq. There was a shift in rationale. Apparently it was a concern about bookkeeping there.
Bustle before the forum
The crowd in Bender Arena consists of hundreds of people chatting excitedly before the forum begins. It is clear that all members of the AU community-- undergrads, grad students, alumni, faculty members, and AU neighbors-- are present and eager to hear what the speakers tonight have to say on current events in the nation and around the world. Many members of the Kennedy Political Union line the very front seats, dressed to the nines in hopes of getting a picture with one of the three famous panelists. At a school like American University, where political discussions are frequent and often heated, this atmosphere comes as no surprise. Stay tuned for more on what issues the panel will adjust, and whether the Ragin' Cajun and Mr. Bolton will agree or disagree on these hot topics.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)